Article
Subtle signs of racial biases among lower secondary teachers in Portugal
This research study sought to answer the question: “Do teachers make different recommendations depending on whether students are Black or White?”. It also intended to provide an insight on whether teachers’ recommendations and expectations regarding Black and White students’ school pathways may be influenced by their potentially biased perceptions of achievement and behaviour.
The results of the survey provide no clear and robust evidence of systematic biases among Portuguese White teachers towards Black students. However, several important exceptions reveal subtle signs of such biases. In particular, the results show that information about performance and behaviour is mobilised in such a way that some recommendations favour White students while others are unfavourable to Black ones. Furthermore, the simple fact that a student was White or Black was enough to prompt different word choices within open-ended questions.
-
1A national-level sample showed no strong consistent pattern of biases among White teachers in their perceptions of and recommendations for White and Black students in Portugal towards their future school pathways, although important exceptions were found.
-
2Teachers mobilised information about behaviour and performance in such a way that they made specific biased recommendations depending on whether the student was White or Black.
-
3Although there were no statistically significant differences between teachers with different sociodemographic characteristics, a consistent trend indicates that inexperienced teachers, as opposed to experienced ones, show subtle signs of biased perceptions and recommendations that favour White students.
-
4When referring to a student, teachers made different word choices depending on whether he was White or Black.